OR adoption: where it stalls and where it is ready
Optimisation projects stall at the data, at daily use and at ownership after the consultants leave, not at the solver. The evidence is 37 named cases in section 2, each with a stage, a missing layer and one source, and every other section links down to them.
A buyer-side field study of why optimisation projects stall, built from practitioner voices in eight language regions and restructured on 2026-11-12 around one table of named cases. Each section orders those cases one way only: by the stage where they stalled, by problem type, by region, and by the layer the solver depended on.
Main questions answered
- At which stage of the pipeline do projects stall, and what does the planner fall back to?
- Which named companies and projects stalled, at what, and what happened?
- Which problem types are ready for optimisation and which keep stalling?
- Which regions show readiness signals, and where can buyers be heard?
- What does a working optimisation depend on besides the solver?
- Why is optimisation sold as consulting rather than as a product?
How to read this page
The contents list on the left lists this report's panes and sections.
Subsections open collapsed and show their first block; "more" and "less" toggle one, "Expand all" opens every subsection.
Select text and press h to highlight it. Highlights are kept in this browser only.
0. The finding in short
Operations research (OR, i.e. mathematical optimisation of plans) rarely fails at the solver. Across eight language regions projects stall at data, daily use and ownership. Around 65 % of APS programmes miss their expected return, with poor data management among the top five reasons (McKinsey, n = 80); only about 10 % of companies have fully completed their APS deployment (McKinsey figure, second-hand). At a Rotterdam haulier 80 % of the plan still changes after the first trip (TNO 2022). The pull is a missing person: 53 % of 502 German logistics firms lack dispatchers (Bitkom 2026).
How to read this page: section 2 is the evidence. Every stage in section 1, every problem type in section 3, every region in section 4 and every dependency in section 5 links down to rows of that one table. Where the 2026-10-16 study did not state an attribution as a sourced fact, it is marked "(Claude's reading)".
1. Where projects stall: the seven stages
flowchart LR S1[1 Problem awareness] --> S2[2 Will and budget] --> S3[3 Data] --> S4[4 Implementation] --> S5[5 Daily use and trust] --> S6[6 Monitoring] --> S7[7 Keeping it alive]
| Stage | What it looks like on the floor | Cases that stalled here | One quote |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Problem awareness | The buyer knows something is wrong but cannot state the objective, the constraints or what a better result would look like; planning runs on one experienced person's judgement. | No named case; the study has only quotes for this stage. | "The primary danger is that the client does not know what production planning actually is in the context of his firm."Ondřej Komenda (inSophy), IT Systems 7-8/2013 · systemonline.cz |
| 2 Will and budget | Money is rarely the missing ingredient: firms lack the people and the time, the margins of those who need it most are too thin, and those who paid saw turnover rise and profit stay flat. | CIUSSS MCQ nurses · Activa Industria 4.0 · tyre distributor · sports-league scheduler | "Turnover rises by tens of percent but profit does not rise at all or even falls."Komenda (inSophy, APS maker, against interest), IT Systems 9/2014 · systemonline.cz |
| 3 Data | The real rules live in planners' heads, master data is missing or stale, and capturing and cleaning it becomes most of the project. | machining SME ERP · steel radiator plant MES | "Ask a veteran material planner 'what is the normal lead time for this part?' and he says 'which supplier? A is usually 7 days, B needs 10, C is hit and miss, you have to chase.' None of this is written in Excel."APS implementer, CSDN bbs, undated · bbs.csdn.net |
| 4 Implementation and integration | Vague requirements, interfaces that do not quite match, and an IT department that will not support what it did not build; a small mismatch at the interface becomes a physical error on the floor. | FloraHolland thesis · Chilean mining pilots · Relog at a parts distributor · DELMIA Ortems load test · injection-moulding APS · Cainiao France station · car-rental DSS | "ERP operation numbers were 10, 20, 30; APS used 1, 2, 3. No conversion was done ... the shop executed in ERP order: 30 first, then 10, then 20, and product quality failed."APS implementer, CSDN bbs · bbs.csdn.net |
| 5 Daily use and trust | Planners keep the old way running in parallel, override the plan or drift back to Excel; a plan that is better on paper is worse in practice because it ignores what the people executing it know. | NS Rondje om de kerk · De Lijn · Rijkswaterstaat LP · French APS licence · DGA cutting stock · LTL rostering MIP · 科箭 route optimiser · American Airlines · inspector roster | "Some planners took matters into their own hands and attempted their own validation, for instance by continuing to work in the old system in parallel and checking whether the output was identical. Of course this increased their workload considerably."Decroix, Vereecke, Vanderheyden, De Baets (Vlerick), 26 planner interviews, STAtOR Dec 2024 · vvsor.nl |
| 6 Monitoring and evaluation | No baseline, no definition of a good plan, and the obvious test against yesterday's plan is never run, so the tool cannot defend itself when the budget is reviewed. | Ozon warehouse staffing | "Schedule once before leaving, keep the result, let the solver run all night, compare. I doubt any APS vendor will let you do that test."anonymous 20-year APS consultant via 数据魔术师, 2020 · cloud.tencent.com |
| 7 Keeping it alive | Every change in the business has to be rebuilt into the model and nobody in house can do it; when the champion or the consultants leave, the model freezes or is shelved. | Gelre roster model · rebuilder's routing module · OCP Jorf Lasfar · Hajj scheduling | "For every other department or institution all the specific constraints have to be mapped again and built into the model. You need people with the right knowledge for that. ... Care institutions often do not have the people in house who can do this themselves."N. Hamster, STAtOR July 2026 · vvsor.nl |
2. The cases
Every named case the 2026-10-16 study found, sorted by the stage it stalled at and then by region. "Vendor-told" means the only account is from a seller; "second-hand" means relayed by someone who was not there. "What was missing" names the dependency of section 5. Successes sit at the end with "none" in the stage column; they are the control group.
| # | Who | Problem type | Stalled at | What was missing | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | CIUSSS Mauricie-et-Centre-du-Québec, nursesbuyer · healthcare · Québec | Nurse rostering | 2 Will and budget (Claude's reading: no planning tool was tried; the study files it under labour relations) | not stated | February 2023: after self-scheduling failed to fix staffing, nurses in 7-day units were ordered to work "une fin de semaine sur trois"; the union reported about thirty resignations linked to the change, not confirmed by the employer. Not a software failure: the "solution" was a blunt rule. | ciusssmcq.ca · radio-canada.ca |
| 02 | Activa Industria 4.0, Spanish ministry programmebuyers: manufacturing SMEs · Spain | General planning (subsidised Industry 4.0 consulting) | 2 Will and budget | 5.7 value signal | Free, subsidised consulting was cut on 2025-01-29 from EUR 24.42 M and 3,300 SMEs to EUR 14.8 M and 2,000 SMEs: "la previsión inicial ... ha sido notablemente superior a la realidad". Demand fell about 40 % short. | boe.es PDF |
| 03 | Tyre distributor with about 850 purchase ordersbuyer, told on r/supplychain · tyre distribution · US | Inventory and lot sizing | 2 Will and budget (Claude's reading) | not stated | Evaluated o9, Logility, Relex and Netstock; "Kinaxis pretty much admitted they were overkill." | reddit.com |
| 04 | Sports-league schedulerbuilder posting on r/OperationsResearch · sports · English baseline | Timetabling | 2 Will and budget (Claude's reading) | 5.7 value signal | A constraint-programming model for a league; the Timefold founder's reply: "As a product, capturing 10% of that 3-4M USD value is very unlikely. As as service, maybe. The biggest problem? It's only scheduled once a year." | reddit.com |
| 05 | Machining SME, employee u/Trash133buyer, first-person · machining · Germany | Production planning (ERP planning module) | 3 Data | 5.2 data integration | An ERP bought eight years earlier is used only for invoices and delivery notes, no production planning or stock management, because of "die fehlenden Stücklisten und Arbeitsgänge" and nobody with machining knowledge to maintain them. Replies: doomed "ohne Unterstützung aus höheren Ebenen". Post truncated in the archive. | reddit.com |
| 06 | Steel radiator plant, MES project told by Vasily Karpovimplementer, first-person · discrete manufacturing · Russia | Production scheduling | 3 Data (Claude's reading) | 5.1 monitoring infrastructure | The plant had no routings; technologists built them with stopwatches. Per-order cost labels were abandoned after a customer complained about jammed printers, and the director disabled traceability: "Люди очень болезненно относятся к тому, что за ними следят" (people react very painfully to being watched). | habr.com |
| 07 | Royal FloraHolland, TU Delft thesis (Binneveld 2017)buyer via thesis · auction logistics · Netherlands | Order-handling simulation | 4 Implementation (Claude's reading) | 5.4 simulation: it stayed one | The simulation found the coordinating system "based on a fixed relation between auction and distribution which limits the control over the process" and proposed new controllers; the record gives no sign the redesign was implemented. | repository.tudelft.nl |
| 08 | Chilean mining pilots (Deloitte Chile, CESCO, Accenture)consultancy and association sources · mining · Chile | General (fleet, maintenance, AI) | 4 Implementation | 5.2 data integration (silos), 5.7 value signal | 74 % of miners name resistance to change as the main brake, 61 % a business-technology gap; pilots of three to six months are too short and sites too different: "El principal desafío no está en la adopción inicial de tecnología, sino en su escalamiento." Full report behind a form, sample size unknown. | deloitte.com · cesco.cl |
| 09 | Relog routing SaaS at a B2B parts distributor, told by Vladislav Prozorovbuyer, first-person, 5 vehicles · parts distribution · Russia | Routing | 4 Implementation | 5.2 data integration | Six-month prepayment, bugs, five-minute solves, an unresponsive manager, traffic data sold as Yandex that turned out to be 2GIS; the 1C module covered only part of the data exchange and took two months of in-house work; training calls cost 17,500 roubles; the refund took two months and a formal claim. Yandex Routing was kept. | vc.ru |
| 10 | DELMIA Ortems load test, CS Group / Dassaultvendor-told · large discrete plant · Russia | Production scheduling | 4 Implementation (Claude's reading) | not stated: solve time of the previous system was the limit | The customer's previously chosen system "не смогла рассчитать план по исходным данным" (could not compute a plan from the source data); 7-level BOMs, 69,969 chained operations; detailed scheduling of 208,103 operations took about 13 hours. Told against the previous vendor. | habr.com |
| 11 | Injection-moulding APS, told by salesman 章月洲 about a competitorvendor-told · discrete manufacturing · China | Production scheduling (APS) | 4 Implementation (Claude's reading) | not stated | Implemented and charged workshop by workshop ("上线一个车间收取一个车间项目费用"), so coordination stayed offline; kitting across casting, machining, sub-assembly and final assembly was "假齐套" (fake); the project could not be sustained and the client's PMC and IT head resigned. | sohu.com |
| 12 | Cainiao's France parcel station, told by 张鑫航buyer's account of a vendor product · parcel logistics · China, operating in France | Routing | 4 Implementation (Claude's reading) | 5.2 data integration: address parsing abroad (Claude's reading) | Third-party routing was too slow with many parcels unassigned, heavy overlaps, slow support and high fees: "没有人工调度员,完全依赖算法结果;国外地址解析准确率低" (no human dispatcher, poor address parsing abroad). Replaced by the in-house team. | sohu.com |
| 13 | Car-rental reservation decision support, consultant-builtsecond-hand, relayed from a Carravilla talk · car rental · Portugal, told in English | Pricing and revenue (reservations) | 4 Implementation | 5.2 data integration (Claude's reading: "a lot of work involved in providing the necessary data inputs") | "considerably more efficient than the existing solution", but the data inputs were laborious and "the IT department wasn't willing to support it." Dropped. | or.stackexchange.com |
| 14 | NS "Rondje om de kerk"buyer · rail · Netherlands | Crew rostering | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading) | 5.7 value signal (the study files the outcome under value: it went negative) | 2001 efficiency rosters bound crews to at most two routes a day; strikes in 2000 and 2001; afterwards NS "had meer personeel nodig, terwijl tegelijkertijd het zieketeverzuim enorm steeg"; hundreds of trains cancelled daily for months; NS dropped it. "enorme weerstand onder conducteurs en machinisten". Method or software not stated; 2015 retrospective. | treinreiziger.nl |
| 15 | De Lijn, Leuven and Tielt-Winge depotsbuyer · public transport · Flanders | Rostering, timetabling | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading) | not stated | October 2024: spontaneous strike over January rosters tied to a network overhaul. Union: "de samenstelling van de diensten is totaal onlogisch" and drivers had no say. Tool not named. | vrt.be |
| 16 | Rijkswaterstaat road programme LP, described by Timmer (ORTEC) in 1994buyer · public works · Netherlands | Road programme LP | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading) | 5.4 simulation and what-if (the study files it there) | The LP solution "is vaak moeilijk te verkopen" (is often hard to sell); the model was rebuilt year by year "zodanig dat deze beter is te volgen" (so that it is easier to follow). | vvsor.nl PDF |
| 17 | Unnamed industrial company, told by its S&OP managerbuyer · industry · France | APS / S&OP | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading) | not stated | APS licence not renewed after three years because planners and sales never used it. The page returned 404 on 2026-10-16; the wording survives only in a search-engine snippet and could not be verified. | blog.lean-supply-chain.fr (404) |
| 18 | DGA cutting stockbuyer · defence · France | Cutting and packing | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading: taken up once explained) | 5.6 evaluator, in the form of explainability | The tool's outputs had to be explained "pour que les chefs s'en emparent" (so that the commanders take ownership). | roadef.org bulletin 45 |
| 19 | LTL driver-rostering MIP, told by Lozhkinsin-house builder, first-person · LTL trucking · Russia | Workforce rostering | 5 Daily use and trust | 5.3 action loop | Survived as "Калькулятор в комбинации с умелым пользователем" (a calculator in combination with a skilled user) rather than as an autonomous optimiser, with a claimed 14 % saving on long-leg looped routes. | habr.com |
| 20 | Unnamed logistics firm, told by 科箭 TMSvendor-told, against interest · logistics · China | Routing | 5 Daily use and trust | 5.5 uncertainty, tacit rules | Routes 8 % shorter, complaints up 30 %: the algorithm ignored customers who do not receive in the morning, old estates where big trucks cannot enter, drivers unfamiliar with routes; "a plan that looks good but cannot be executed". | qt-asia.com |
| 21 | American Airlines irregular-operations recovery, told by Doug Graybuyer-side speaker on a vendor blog · airlines · US | Crew recovery | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading) | 5.3 action loop; 5.6 evaluator (supplied later at Southwest, case 37) | The team "wrote the math and handed it over without engaging users. Data was scattered, and users doubted a computer could solve the problem. After six months, there was no traction." | nextmv.io |
| 22 | Inspector rostering prototypepublic sector · English baseline | Workforce rostering | 5 Daily use and trust (Claude's reading) | 5.7 value signal | "Because the prototype focused only on using fewer inspectors, the unions shot it down." The study bundles this quote with Nextmv, Reddit and Timefold sources; that the Timefold post carries it is Claude's reading. | timefold.ai |
| 23 | Ozon warehouse staffingcompany release · e-commerce warehouse · Russia | Warehouse staff movement | 6 Monitoring and evaluation (Claude's reading) | 5.6 evaluator, 5.7 value signal | Claimed 418 km less staff movement between warehouse floors; no baseline given. | retail.ru |
| 24 | Gelre hospital roster model, N. Hamsterbuilder, Twente student · healthcare · Netherlands | Workforce rostering | 7 Keeping it alive | not stated as a layer; people in house to rebuild the constraints | The model survives only because Gelre has an integrated capacity-management team; 200+ organisations contacted her after a bachelor thesis; "Zorginstellingen hebben zelf vaak niet de mensen in huis die dit zelf kunnen." Several validation rounds were needed because constraints had not come up in earlier talks. | vvsor.nl PDF |
| 25 | In-house routing module at a wholesale distributor, told by "rebuilder"in-house developer, first-person · wholesale distribution · Russia | Routing | 7 Keeping it alive (Claude's reading) | 5.1 monitoring (trackers destroyed), 5.7 value signal (self-estimated) | The module ran seven years because its single author stayed; map tiles had to be refreshed every six months and the hardware was obsolete. Drivers destroyed 9 trackers in three years because fuel "savings" were part of their pay. Fuel saving 10 to 12 %, self-estimated. | habr.com |
| 26 | OCP Jorf Lasfarbuyer; academic implementation report with OCP co-authors · process industry and mining · Morocco | Production scheduling, vessel assignment | 7 Keeping it alive | 5.6 evaluator (weights "found by trial and error"); also 5.2 (.lp files) and 5.5 (tacit rules not modelled) | A commercial MILP optimiser ran 10 hours to a poor schedule; planners scheduled by hand for over five years, having "witnessed the ineffectiveness"; rescued from 2020 by local researchers who reverse-engineered the .lp files and met planners up to 2 to 3 times a week; now feeding SAP; claimed +5 % turnover. | gerad.ca PDF |
| 27 | Hajj stoning-ritual scheduling, Helbing et al.ministry-funded academic build · public sector · Saudi Arabia | Timetabling, pedestrian routing | 7 Keeping it alive (Claude's reading) | 5.3 action loop (the study files the hand-over there) | MIP and QP credited with no crowd deaths 2007 to 2014; by 2015 the authors and ministry "no longer handled scheduling and routing for that ritual"; 2015 disaster. The paper does not say why it failed. Edelman-finalist status from search snippets only. | iaorifors.com |
| 28 | Woodworkers on woodworker.de, BESTOPTbuyers, first-person · woodworking craft · Germany | Cutting and packing | none: in use | none; the value is countable | A cutting optimiser at about 250 EUR (2009) "bei einem Auftrag schon alleine ca. 200 Euro gespart" (saved about 200 EUR on one order). A 2026 thread meets a new optimiser SaaS with "Insellösung" and liability objections (woodworker.de 2026). | woodworker.de 2009 |
| 29 | VieCuri hospital, ORTEC Harmonybuyer, vendor-adjacent report · healthcare · Netherlands | Workforce rostering | none: bought for another reason | 5.7 value signal came from compliance, not optimality | Moved from Excel in 2012/13 because the system "gekoppeld kan worden" to the ERP and to be "zeker ... dat er volgens de cao wordt geroosterd" (sure rostering follows the collective agreement). | computable.nl |
| 30 | Agrifirm Belgiumbuyer, vendor-adjacent report · animal feed distribution · Belgium | Routing | none: bought for another reason | 5.7 value signal: the trigger was the pay structure | Manual routing replaced after "De beslissing om de betaalstructuur van de transporteurs te veranderen" (the decision to change how carriers are paid). Savings claims not used by the study. | computable.nl |
| 31 | Van Berkel Logistics, TNO "Talking Trucks"buyer, field study for SmartPort · container trucking · Netherlands | Routing | none: evaluated in three live trials | 5.1 monitoring (80 % of the plan changes intraday) and 5.5 (soft data had to be digitised first); 5.6 was supplied by TNO | Three live trials with the planners' own plans as the benchmark gave "een vergelijkbare (en zelfs iets verbeterde) punctualiteit en capaciteitsbenutting". Information reaches planners by WhatsApp, phone, radio and a counter where drivers ask questions. | tno.nl PDF |
| 32 | SNCF OPTIPLACEbuyer, in-house · rail · France | Pricing and revenue (seat assignment) | none: in production since summer 2024 | none; "une phase de marche à blanc" (a dry run) stood in for 5.4 and 5.6 | The seat-assignment optimiser went to production in summer 2024 after a dry-run phase. | roadef.org bulletin 46 |
| 33 | TRW Automotive, told by Plaček (Merz) in 2008user · automotive · Czechia | Production scheduling (APS) | none: in use where machines can switch products | 5.7 value signal exists only under a condition | APS pays off only where machines can make alternative products and where sales is not the bottleneck. | systemonline.cz |
| 34 | DP World Jebel Ali berth plannerbuyer · port · UAE | Berth planning | none: rules-based tool in use (2011) | not stated | Rules-based rather than optimising, so the team could "focus our manual planning expertise on exceptions". | joc.com |
| 35 | 上汽安吉物流 (SAIC Anji Logistics)buyer, in-house · vehicle logistics · China | Routing, vehicle loading | none: usage above 90 % since 2016 | none stated | ORSC application prize 2020; the system's usage has stayed above 90 % since 2016. | sugli.sjtu.edu.cn |
| 36 | Home-made scheduler in one plant, from the 200-factories essay by 邬爱其academic essay, not a dataset · manufacturing SME · China | Production scheduling | none: in use | none; value counted as utilisation | Full digitalisation at 2 to 3 % net margin "needs 20 years to pay back", so most firms "squeeze efficiency out of management"; one plant's home-made scheduling system lifted utilisation from 60 % to 85 %, "这些都不需要什么高科技" (none of this needs high tech). | 36kr.com |
| 37 | Southwest Airlines, told by Doug Graybuyer-side speaker on a vendor blog · airlines · US | Crew scheduling | none: accepted after a year of contests | none; 5.6 was built by sitting with a dispatch supervisor | OR PhDs sat with a veteran dispatch supervisor for a year of validation "contests" against human planners before the model won acceptance; a greedy-versus-optimised crew schedule test showed about $100m a year difference. | nextmv.io |
37 rows: 27 stalls and 10 that did not stall. The 2026-10-16 study said "Fifteen short ones" above its failure table while the table had 17 rows; the 17 are rows 01, 02, 05, 06, 08 to 15, 17, 20, 21, 26 and 27 here, and the other 20 cases were scattered through its text, matrices and quotes. No German, Polish, Spanish, Latin American or Gulf company was found describing its own abandoned optimisation project in its own words; the German, French and Spanish lanes searched for this directly and got vendor and consultant pages back.
3. Problem types
All 21 problem types the study names: the 10 of its framework and the 11 named only in a case or a quote. "Ready or not" repeats the study's own judgment where it gave one.
| Problem type | Verticals where it was seen | Cases | Typical stall | Ready or not |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Routing (VRP, last mile) | Logistics and transport; retail and e-commerce (platforms in-house); public sector (Hajj); mining fleet dispatch | 09 12 20 25 27 30 31 35 | Daily use and trust: driver and dispatcher acceptance; address and time-window data that "never end" | Ready where the dispatcher is missing. Mature in platforms (JD, Cainiao, Meituan, SF, Yandex, Ozon, Dodo) and parcel (DHL, GOR prize 2016); stalls at small operators, mid-size hauliers and drivers everywhere; the pull is the dispatcher shortage (section 4). |
| Workforce rostering, staffing | Healthcare; rail and public transport; airlines; warehouses; public sector; LTL trucking | 01 14 15 19 22 24 29 | Daily use and trust: staff acceptance, fairness, opacity; packages do not fit local rules; nobody in house to maintain a bespoke model | Ready to buy, not to use. Healthcare has the clearest problem and the weakest use; "not ready to use without an in-house capacity team" (hospitals with capacity-management teams: Gelre, Radboudumc, ZGT). |
| Production scheduling, machine assignment (APS) | Discrete manufacturing; process industry; energy incumbents | 05 06 10 11 26 33 36 | Data: master data (BOMs, routings, standard times), the missing feedback loop, planner tacit knowledge not in the model | Mature at head firms only. Chinese auto parts, batteries and electronics above RMB 400 m revenue, Russian electrical and machine building, Czech automotive forging, French groups; below the large tier "back to Excel" is the standard ending and consultancies advise SMEs against full APS (shares in section 4). |
| Inventory and lot sizing | Discrete manufacturing; retail and e-commerce; tyre distribution | 03 | Data: supplier lead times in planners' heads; conflicting departmental KPIs; solutions swing under small data changes | Czech large firms, not SMEs. 84 % of large Czech firms vs 43 % of SMEs use inventory analytics (section 4); a Spanish planner sets stock "a ojo"; mid-size retailers find the suites overkill. |
| Network and facility design | Rail and intercity coach (Flix, DB); energy (GRTgaz, Lhyfe); e-commerce (JD, 永辉); process (OCP supply-chain model); auction logistics | 07 26 | Implementation: a thesis stayed a simulation; a capex study was rejected by a CEO over the discount rate (no source given by the study) | Inside incumbents and platforms only. Nothing on SMEs in any region; in-house with university partners, or consulting for one-off studies. |
| Cutting and packing | Woodworking craft; parcel (Cainiao carton selection); vehicle logistics; defence; garment (China) | 18 28 35 | Implementation: integration with existing systems and liability for wrong cuts; sector rules absent from generic products | Ready at craft level, cheaply. A 250 EUR tool pays back on one order; new entrants face "Insellösung" and liability objections; not found at all in NL, ES, PL, CZ, RU, Gulf or English sources. |
| Pricing and revenue | Rail (SNCF, ÖBB yield); airlines (Amadeus); TV advertising (TF1); car rental; public auctions (FCC) | 13 32 | Implementation: IT willingness to run it; otherwise not documented from the user side | In-house at incumbents only. No SME or mid-market evidence anywhere; X5's retail pricing is under NDA. |
| Maintenance planning | Energy (EDF nuclear outages); rail (DB); mining (Chile pilots) | 08 | Not documented: "no user voice in any region" | No user voice found. Appears only in subsidy lists (Argentina KIT 4.0, Opolskie) and Gulf IoT counts; in-house where it exists. |
| Timetabling | Rail (DB, ÖBB, SNCF); public transport; public sector (Hajj); ports (TPS Valparaíso); sports leagues | 04 15 27 | Keeping it alive: hand-over from external builders; frequency of use too low for a product | Mature at rail incumbents. Prototypes industrialised at DB, ÖBB and SNCF; elsewhere government-funded academic builds that die at hand-over. |
| General planning (APS, S&OP, IBP) | Discrete manufacturing; process; logistics; retail; everywhere below the large tier | 02 05 08 17 | Daily use and trust: a parallel Excel plan; governance ("refuse d'arbitrer"); no plan owner | Bought widely, finished rarely. About 10 % of APS deployments completed, 65 % miss ROI (section 0); S&OP "devient un rituel"; "APS沦为高级Excel"; consultant dependence after go-live (Chalmers). Excel shares by region in section 4. |
| Crew recovery (irregular operations) | Airlines | 21 37 | Daily use and trust: handed over without engaging users | No judgment on the old page for this type; airlines sit in its readiest group, "scheduling-heavy service incumbents" (section 4). |
| Berth planning | Ports (UAE) | 34 | None recorded: rules-based tool in use | No judgment on the old page. |
| Vessel assignment | Process industry and mining (OCP) | 26 | Keeping it alive | No judgment on the old page beyond OCP being "a ready owner". |
| Order-handling simulation | Auction logistics (FloraHolland) | 07 | Implementation: stayed a simulation | No judgment on the old page. |
| Port and container-yard scheduling | Container port (China, 王磊 at Alibaba Cloud) | none in the table; one practitioner talk: "poor equipment positioning data ... external truck drivers not switching on the positioning app" (zhihu.com) | Data and monitoring | No judgment on the old page. |
| Fleet dispatch (mining) | Mining (Chile) | 08 | Implementation: scaling pilots across sites | Ready in Chilean large mining. Large miners have run fleet dispatch for decades; medium miners are "presumed" not to have fleet systems (vendor deck, sonami.cl); consulting-heavy, no user voice. |
| Parcel volume forecasting | Postal (Österreichische Post, node level) | none in the table; presented at an ÖGOR workshop (PMO 107 PDF) | not stated | No judgment on the old page. |
| Warehouse staff movement | E-commerce warehouse (Ozon) | 23 | Monitoring and evaluation: no baseline | No judgment on the old page. |
| Road programme LP (public works) | Public sector (Rijkswaterstaat) | 16 | Daily use and trust: hard to sell, rebuilt yearly | No judgment on the old page. |
| Pedestrian routing | Public sector (Hajj) | 27 | Keeping it alive | No judgment on the old page. |
| Appointment and slot booking | Ports (TPS Valparaíso) | none in the table; a container appointment system taken up voluntarily, no numbers (mundomaritimo.cl) | None recorded | Taken up voluntarily, no numbers. The study counts Chilean ports with large mining as the one ready Latin American pocket. |
4. Regions
One row per language region as the study names them. The numbers are the proxies the lanes could open; none measures OR adoption directly. Vendor-commissioned and vendor-sample surveys are marked. The readiness verdict is the study's own.
| Region | Pull signal, with the sourced numbers | Dominant buying path | Readiness verdict | Where buyers can be heard | Cases |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Germany, Austria, Switzerland | 37 % of German supply chains planned purely on Excel or Excel plus standalone tools vs 18 % global (IDC for Kinaxis, vendor-commissioned, logistik-heute.de); 70 % MS Office at detailed scheduling in Austrian mid-sized manufacturers, 44 % able to capture machine feedback automatically (2011, TU Wien); PPS software at 67 % of manufacturers (2015, Fraunhofer ISI); Excel first for warehouse staff planning (Fraunhofer IML); 53 % of 502 logistics firms lack dispatchers, 73 % lack know-how, 55 % see AI as the answer, money last at 48 % (Bitkom 2026); data analytics at 3 % of the Mittelstand (KfW Fokus 554), large R&D-intensive firms spend 19 times small ones and the share completing digitalisation projects fell to 30 % (KfW 2025); interfaces a top ERP problem at about 19 % of 1,538 ratings (Trovarit); 35 routing vendors at 5,000 to 20,000 EUR (Fraunhofer SCS); works councils demand traceable criteria under BetrVG § 87 (Böckler); in-house OR groups "im Wesentlichen aufgelöst" into IT (Gabler); GOR about 1,050 members (GOR 2025). | Product: APS from ERP and MES vendors, small routing vendors; in-house at DB, ÖBB, Flix, Sixt | Forced in road logistics; mature rail | GOR PMO working group (practitioner workshops hosted by companies, 111th Munich 2026-11-26/27) · PMO 107 at ÖBB · woodworker.de | 05 28 |
| Netherlands and Flanders | Hospital rosters by hand "vrijwel overal"; 200+ organisations contacted one student (STAtOR 2026); 80 % of a haulier's plan changes intraday (TNO); shippers self-rated 6.1/10 in 2018 (Computable); 4 % of AI-using firms use it for logistics, transport flat at 7, 4, 7 % 2023 to 2025 (CBS); 7 in 10 Flemish SMEs have no digitalisation plan, 53 % no tool to share information between departments, 72 % no data analysis (Vlaamse Regering); Regioroster funded on the hypothesis that preference rosters give 15 to 20 % more hours (Dinalog); Dinalog 250+ projects, EUR 100 m+ (dinalog.nl); VIL AI-readiness programme from Q4 2026 (vil.be); AI-BIPTO proof of concept with no deployment (Dinalog). | Product for the standard case (ORTEC Harmony, bought for compliance); bespoke university MILP for hard constraints; subsidised pilots; dense supply side (ORTEC, Quintiq, AIMMS, CQM) | Ready in hospitals with capacity teams | STAtOR archive (practitioner column by John Poppelaars) · LNMB conference (January, Soesterberg) · TKI Dinalog | 07 14 15 16 24 29 30 31 |
| France and Québec | No adoption survey; large groups keep OR in-house, everyone else outsources or buys, unchanged 2011 to 2019 (ROADEF white paper); mid-market "planning is just done in Excel" (Hexaly founder, vendor, nextmv.io); 60 % of industrial firms on an ERP (DGE Théma 24); 60 % of guichet subsidy money bought industry-3.0 equipment (Deloitte for the government); 17 % can deploy 4.0 at the planned pace (Wavestone); EDI connections took 6 months for one cyclologistics operator (Les Boîtes à Vélo). Québec: qualified staff 79 % and time 75 % named before money, ROI hard to evaluate 48 %, digital integration "fait du surplace", robots next to paper work orders (STIQ 2021); 66 % of PME directly hit by the labour shortage (FCEI 2023); 33 % have not recouped their automation investment, 30 % used a private consultant, shortage as motive 59 % (FCEI 2025, n = 352). | In-house at EDF, SNCF, GRTgaz, Renault, Orange; consulting (Eurodécision) and APS integrators for the rest; Québec: consulting and public bodies for automation | Ready inside incumbents, not PME | ROADEF 2026 Tours (industrial feedback session: Renault, RTE, EDF) · Prix Indus'RO · JOPT 2026 Montréal | 01 17 18 32 |
| Spain and Latin America | No OR survey; among non-adopters 78 to 82 % lack skills, 44 to 53 % cite data, cost cited by 68.61 % of micro firms and 72.61 % of 10-49 firms (INE via IndesIA 2024); 0.9 % of manufacturing SMEs with identifiable AI (IndesIA 2026); 42 % of logistics SMEs claim AI (Eurobarometer via Cadena de Suministro); driver deficit 20,000 (UNO) to 30,000 (trans.info), 18.8 % foreign workers in transport (Cadena de Suministro); public tenders EUR 578,512 for a Defence hospital shift system (BOE) and EUR 507,387 in Galicia (Galiciapress). Chile: 74 % resistance to change, 61 % business-technology gap (REDIMIN); supplier maturity rising (Alta Ley). Colombia: 3.9 % of Bogotá manufacturing SMEs use specialised data software (Revista Mutis). Peru: planning effectiveness about 65 %, secondary (LACCEI 2026). Argentina: KIT 4.0 at 50 % co-financing (programme note); SMEs build improvised ad hoc APS (JAIIO 2015). Mexico: every practitioner page returned 403. | Product (routing SaaS, APS with integrator); mine fleet systems; in-house ad hoc in Argentine SMEs; consulting as rescue | Latent; Chilean mining and ports | SEIO working groups · ICHIO OPTIMA (145 talks in 2025) · CESCO; Spanish forums silent except one 2014 Forocoches planner | 02 08 |
| Poland, Czechia and Slovakia, Russian-speaking space | Poland: 2 % APS among 350 manufacturers in 2016 (vendor survey, BPSC); ERP 39.8 % in 2017 (Siemens) and 30 % in 2025 (DPS via ITwiz); Industry 4.0 in 12 to 14 % of Opolskie firms (Opolskie); no planner voice despite nine queries. Czechia: routing analytics 68 % of large firms vs 18 % of SMEs, inventory analytics 84 % vs 43 %, 23 % of SMEs integrate data centrally, SME intent on routing (28 %) above large firms (23 %) (207 directors, NCP 4.0 2023); 71 % of large manufacturers plan in Excel, 45 % plan under one week (vendor sample, Adastra). Russian-speaking: 1,700+ machine builders with digital twins at 12 %, big data 16 %, AI agents 3 % (HSE ISSEK); about ten domestic APS products since 2022 (sponsored, BIA); state as driver, "недостаток систематизированных данных" (Expert.ru); Yandex Routing driver app rated 2.0 from 55 (RuStore). | Poland: integrators (ASTOR, Streamsoft, DSR) with vendor prose; Czechia: APS product with integrators, "audit, process, then software"; Russian-speaking: consulting-led planning (Rightstep), routing SaaS down to five-vehicle firms, in-house at Yandex, Ozon, X5, Dodo | Czech gap measured; Poland silent | IT Systems (APS argued in public since 2008) · NCP 4.0 Analýza · Habr comment threads and Telegram PRO Планирование (697 subscribers); Poland: Meetup Produkcyjny | 06 09 10 19 23 25 33 |
| Gulf, Egypt, Morocco | Only digital maturity is measured: 479 Saudi factories SIRI-assessed by mid-2024 against a target of 4,000 (Asharq Al-Awsat); 620+ UAE factories under ITTI with a 40 % productivity claim and no baseline (The National); AI adoption 33.1 %, transport and storage 44.4 %, no planning indicator (GASTAT via Middle East AI News); two thirds of 139 GCC organisations stuck in pilots, 11 % with financial return (McKinsey via The National); human capital the lowest score in a Saudi manufacturing survey, n = 150 (Alkhalefah); about EUR 2 bn a year of consulting, "Ministry of McKinsey" (SWP); addresses lack street names, merchants ask for the nearest landmark (Raqi). Morocco: OCP's rescued scheduler claims +5 % turnover (GERAD), Edelman finalist 2021 (Financial Afrik). Egypt: nothing found, OECD review returned 403. | Consulting at state level; products via subsidised roadmaps; no Gulf user review of any APS or routing product; Morocco: consulting, then academic rescue and an in-house Business Steering Group | Ready on paper, unknown in practice | IEOM GCC conference (academic-heavy); no Arabic planner community found, Reddit empty | 26 27 34 |
| China | Intelligent APS penetration 3 to 4 %, 10 % of discrete manufacturers have "tried or discussed" it, customers mainly above RMB 400 m revenue, self-built APS "基本没有成功案例" (investor survey, 高鹄资本); 86.92 % of SMEs at basic informatisation, subsidies concentrated on hardware (中国城市报); a moderately deep project about RMB 1.5 m, 30 pilot cities, 15,000+ SMEs (学习时报); hiring difficulty at 46.5 % of 955 Jiangsu manufacturers (NDRC); vendor projects of 4 to 8 months at RMB 0.5 to 2 m (安达发); project deals in the millions of RMB, scaling with headcount (杉数 via 爱分析); JD Retail claims RMB 500 m saved in 2024 and no commercial-solver dependence, self-reported (JD); domestic solver push (COPT, MindOpt, OptVerse) under 信创 (ORSC); OR team sizes by company (CSDN). | In-house at platforms and large firms (Meituan, Alibaba, JD, Cainiao, SF); vendor projects in manufacturing; consultants as translators | Ready in-house at the top | 运筹OR帷幄 (44,070 followers, monthly meetups) · ORSC enterprise OR division meeting (Xi'an, 2026-10-23 to 25) · Zhihu APS threads | 11 12 20 35 36 |
| English baseline (US, UK, Nordics; India, Ireland, Australia searched, nothing OR-specific) | Over 92 % of surveyed companies own ERP and APS, yet planners work in spreadsheets and write back to the system as a record (Cecere); of 211 respondents under 30 % satisfied with digital transformation (Cecere); 81.1 % of 164 S&OP professionals use Excel or Google Sheets, dedicated tools 5.1 % (author sells training, AbcSupplyChain); about 10 % of APS deployments completed and 65 % missing ROI (section 0); scheduling modules the highest shelfware rate at 15 % in 2003 (AMR); NHS e-rostering mandated by the Carter Review but "immature" (Drake 2017); 46 % of US manufacturers cannot hire schedulers (Deloitte via a vendor page, DecisionBrain); consultancy dependence and parallel systems as onward-phase problems (Chalmers); CSRD and CO2 data in Nordic tenders, five commenters in one thread (r/logistics). | Product (APS, routing SaaS, e-rostering) then consultancy-dependent; in-house at airlines and big tech | Mature in airlines and big tech | OR Stack Exchange, "why OR projects fail" (densest practitioner source) · r/supplychain · EURO Practitioners' Forum 2026 | 03 04 13 21 22 37 |
Where readiness evidence is absent, that is the finding: Poland, Spanish-language forums, Mexico (403), Egypt (403), South Slavic, Taiwan, India, Ireland and Australia, Flemish and French discrete manufacturing, and small French and Québec manufacturers, where the barometer itself says low adoption reflects low interest rather than barriers. No lane found a market where small or mid-sized buyers ask for optimisation in their own words.
5. What a working optimisation depends on
Seven layers around the solver. Each one names the cases of section 2 that lacked it and one voice. The solver itself is almost never what a user complains about.
5.1 Monitoring infrastructure, hardware and software
An optimiser plans from a picture of the current state; if order status, machine state, driver position and breakdowns are not captured and fed back, the plan describes the morning and is re-optimised against nothing. Lacked by 06, 25, 31; the English lane found no user voice on it at all.
"Excel is not the problem, the missing back-channel is ... The plan is not a picture of reality but of what the planner last knew."skillbyte GmbH (consultancy), 2026-08-06 · skillbyte.de
5.2 Data integration, ingestion and silos
Bills of material, routings, standard times, lead times, addresses and time windows pulled from the systems where they live rather than typed again; without it the project becomes a master-data project first and the planner a data clerk. Lacked by 05, 08, 09, 12, 13, 26; the one layer with evidence in all eight lanes.
"Some software is used in part of production by 93 % of large and 74 % of SMEs. Overall digitalisation and data integration is another matter, with much worse results."NCP 4.0, 207 Czech manufacturing directors, 2023 · ncp40.cz
5.3 The action loop: open or closed
Closed means the optimiser's output is what gets executed and the result feeds the next run; open means the output is a suggestion a planner reads, adjusts or ignores while the real plan lives in a spreadsheet. Lacked by 19, 21, 27, and in the study's reading by nearly every daily-use stall in section 1.
"Instead of using the expensive optimizers in these systems, planners work on spreadsheets" and "write the data to the planning systems as a system of record."Lora Cecere, 2025-12 · supplychainshaman.com
5.4 Simulate as well as optimise: a digital twin of the system
A model that can only return "the" optimum cannot answer what planners ask: what if this machine is down, what if we add a standby, what if the time windows are looser. The study found no user asking for this layer in any lane; the nearest ask is "Rückmeldung, schnelle Neuberechnung und gemeinsame Sicht" (skillbyte). Lacked, or stuck at, by 07, 16; covered by a dry run in 32.
Digital twins at 12 %, big data at 16 %, AI agents at 3 % among more than 1,700 machine-building organisations.HSE ISSEK, 2026-03-25 · issek.hse.ru
5.5 Accounting for uncertainty
Real inputs are soft: time windows wider than recorded, drivers' willingness that varies, suppliers that are "hit and miss", rules nobody says out loud. A deterministic model treats them as fixed and its plan breaks on first contact; human planners absorb them in their heads. Lacked by 20, 26, and digitised first in 31.
"Several firms surveyed believe they do a better optimisation job than the software", which does not "see" the relief; the tools "do not make good couriers" and leave them less able to handle surprises.Les Boîtes à Vélo, about 40 cyclologistics operator interviews, April 2025 · lesboitesavelo.org PDF
5.6 Being able to write evaluators
A way to say whether a plan is good without trusting the objective function: a benchmark against the planners' own plan, a plan-execution rate, a dry run, a held-out week. Without one the weights are tuned by feel and parallel running by planners becomes the only test. Lacked by 18, 23, 26; supplied by outsiders or by a year of sitting with planners in 31 and 37. The Spanish lane found no voice on evaluation at all.
The objective was "a weighted sum of several key performance indicators (KPIs) where the weights are found by trial and error"; "Within the company, there was doubt about the DLP's usefulness."Er Raqabi et al. with OCP co-authors, GERAD G-2023-29 · gerad.ca PDF
5.7 Clear signals of real-world value
A measurable link from the plan to money earned or saved, so the project can be judged, defended and kept alive. The corpus is full of savings without baselines and of value that came from somewhere other than the optimiser. Lacked by 02, 04, 08, 14, 22, 23, 25; came from elsewhere in 29, 30, 33; countable in 28 and 36.
Savings "can amount to several tens of percent of costs" if mileage was previously written off from the odometer with no route control, but that comes from mileage control, not routing; with mileage already controlled, routing gains are a few percent.Yevhen Nikushin (FADO), 2019-03-22 · education.ua
5.8 Claude's opinion, not a dataset
6. Consulting vs product
Optimisation is sold as consulting because nobody has found a way to sell it finished. A solver-vendor founder: "I have never once come across a situation where we could help a client adopt an OR solution ... without some consulting, a customised solution, and some integration work", and buyers "don't feel confident they'll be able to keep using the solution without the people who set everything up in the first place" (Nikos Kazazakis, or.stackexchange.com). The French OR society's white paper, unchanged from 2011 to 2019: large groups keep OR in-house, smaller firms outsource or buy off the shelf (roadef.org).
The economics are project-shaped: 杉数's deals run in the millions of RMB and scale with headcount (ifenxi.com); a Chinese APS vendor quotes 4 to 8 months and RMB 0.5 to 2 m (andafa.com); the German routing market is 35 small vendors at 5,000 to 20,000 EUR (Fraunhofer SCS). Where OR is routine it is built inside (DB, ÖBB, GRTgaz, Lhyfe, JD, Cainiao, Yandex, Ozon; see section 4).
The product path is bought widely and finished rarely (shares in section 4). Products are bought for compliance and integration rather than optimality (29, 30) and pay off only under conditions (33); in discrete plants "крайне редко APS-scheduler необходим" (an APS scheduler is rarely necessary; Rightstep, habr.com). Below the large tier they are oversized: "überdimensioniert" for the Mittelstand (skillbyte), "overkill" for an 850-PO distributor (03), rejected by Argentine SMEs who build ad hoc apps (JAIIO 2015). A Chinese selection guide: "软件功能只占30%,实施团队占70%" (success is 30 % software, 70 % implementation team) (bbs.csdn.net).
Neither path displaces Excel plus a skilled planner: in Austrian SMEs individual skill compensates for weak software and only 7 % see the software as decisive (TU Wien); the surviving Russian rostering MIP is a calculator (19); a steel S&OP veteran "became part of the system" (zhihu.com). What pulls that layer out is the planner's absence (section 4).
7. Sources
Every URL cited on this page plus the rest of the 2026-10-16 study's list, by language region. All accessed 2026-10-16 unless marked "not opened" or "404". Vendor sources keep their mark.
Germany, Austria, Switzerland
- bitkom.org: Bitkom press release 2026-09-10, 502 logistics firms.
- repositum.tuwien.at: Lewandowski, TU Wien dissertation 2011.
- isi.fraunhofer.de: Fraunhofer ISI PI 71, 2015 manufacturing survey.
- logistik-heute.de: Logistik Heute 2024-04-18 on IDC survey for Kinaxis (vendor-commissioned).
- iml.fraunhofer.de: Fraunhofer IML press release 2024-04-09.
- kfw.de: KfW Digitalisierungsbericht Mittelstand 2025 (April 2026).
- kfw.de: KfW Fokus Volkswirtschaft 554, 2026-07-29.
- deutscherpresseindex.de: Trovarit "ERP in der Praxis 2026/27" press text.
- boeckler.de: Böckler Impuls 2024/5 reporting WSI-Mitteilungen 1/2024 on algorithmic shift planning.
- gabler.de: Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon.
- gor-ev.de: GOR information page, members, working groups.
- gor-ev.de: GOR working groups including PMO sessions 111 and 112.
- gor-ev.de: GOR company prize winners 2006 to 2026.
- or2025.de: GOR press release 2025-09-03, Minner lecture, 1.
- gor-ev.de: ÖGOR/GOR PMO 107 workshop at ÖBB 2023-09-28/29.
- oegor.wordpress.com: ÖGOR events archive.
- svorasro.wordpress.com: SVOR/ASRO homepage, Swiss OR Days.
- scs.fraunhofer.de: Fraunhofer SCS route-planning software market study 2015/2016 summary (vendor survey).
- skillbyte.de: skillbyte GmbH (consultancy), 2026-08-06.
- reddit.com: r/de_EDV 2022-01-13, machining SME employee.
- software-journal.de: INFORM FELIOS user survey, 29 experts.
- prologistik.com: proLogistik route-planning comparison.
- tetys.de: tetys 2025-02-24, Excel still common.
- woodworker.de: forum thread 2009, cutting-optimiser users.
- woodworker.de: forum thread 2026-07.
- socialeap.de: Socialeap (online marketing agency) 2026-09-15.
- news.it-matchmaker.com: IT-Matchmaker.news (Jürgen Frisch) quoting Dualis (vendor).
Netherlands and Flanders
- vvsor.nl: Telgen, "Besliskunde: beslissen met inzicht".
- vvsor.nl: Timmer (ORTEC), VU inaugural lecture 1994.
- tno.nl: TNO "Eindrapport Talking Trucks" 2022 for SmartPort.
- dinalog.nl: Dinalog news on Van Berkel and Squid (English.
- vvsor.nl: STAtOR 27(2) July 2026, Hamster on doctor rosters.
- vvsor.nl: STAtOR 25(3/4) Dec 2024, Decroix et al. (Vlerick).
- computable.nl: Computable 2018-11-02.
- cbs.nl: CBS 2025-12-12, AI use by companies 2023 to 2025.
- themis.vlaanderen.be: Vlaamse Regering memo May 2024.
- treinreiziger.nl: Treinreiziger 2015-03-30.
- vrt.be: VRT 2024-10-11, De Lijn roster strike.
- computable.nl: Computable 2012-08-06.
- computable.nl: Computable 2013-02-06.
- dinalog.nl: Regioroster project, Nov 2025 to Oct 2026.
- dinalog.nl: TKI Dinalog home, 250+ projects, EUR 100 m+.
- vil.be: VIL "Ready for AI(-agents) in Logistics".
- vvsor.nl: STAtOR archive.
- vvsor.nl: NGB / VVSOR OR section.
- lnmb.nl: LNMB home, event list.
- orbel.be: ORBEL, Belgian OR society.
- utwente.nl: CHOIR, Universiteit Twente.
- supplychainmagazine.nl: S&OP Flavour Day event page.
- repository.tudelft.nl: O. Binneveld, TU Delft MSc thesis 2017.
- dinalog.nl: AI-BIPTO project page, 2021-2024, proof of concept.
France and Québec
- roadef.org: ROADEF white paper 2011, 140 pp..
- roadef.org: ROADEF white paper 2019.
- roadef.org: Bulletin ROADEF 45, Dec 2023, GRTgaz RICE.
- roadef.org: Bulletin ROADEF 46, Dec 2024, SNCF OPTIPLACE, Lhyfe.
- roadef.org: Prix Indus'RO rules and finalists.
- roadef.org: Bulletin index page.
- roadef2026.sciencesconf.org: ROADEF 2026 programme, industrial session.
- nextmv.io: Hexaly founder interview 2025-06-03 (vendor blog.
- entreprises.gouv.fr: DGE Théma 24, Nov 2024, ERP 60 %.
- info.gouv.fr: Deloitte evaluation of the Plan de transformation de l'industrie par le numérique.
- wavestone.com: Wavestone / France Industrie barometer 2024 (consultancy survey.
- stiq.com: STIQ Baromètre industriel québécois 2021.
- cfib-fcei.ca: FCEI Automatisation Québec 2023.
- cfib-fcei.ca: FCEI / Investissement Québec, Oct 2025, n = 352.
- lesboitesavelo.org: Les Boîtes à Vélo, April 2025.
- decisionbrain.com: DecisionBrain 2026-05-08.
- myrhline.com: myRHline 2025-03-04.
- lejournaldelasupplychain.fr: Le Journal de la Supply Chain 2026-06-15.
- ciusssmcq.ca: CIUSSS MCQ notice 2023-02-14.
- radio-canada.ca: Radio-Canada 2023-05-08.
- blog.lean-supply-chain.fr: "S&OP.
- symposia.gerad.ca: Journées de l'optimisation 2026.
- findle.fr: Findle (APS consultancy) 2026-04-23.
- eurodecision.com: Eurodécision (consultancy) 2021.
- woopit.fr: Woopit (vendor) 2023.
- decisionbrain.com: DecisionBrain (vendor) 2020.
Spain and Latin America
- seio.es: SEIO BEIO opinion piece 2024-07-23, author unnamed.
- seio.es: SEIO working groups.
- indesia.org: IndesIA barometer 2024 (industry association).
- indesia.org: IndesIA barometer 2026, manufacturing 0.9 %.
- boe.es: BOE 2025-01-31, Activa Industria 4.0 budget cut.
- boe.es: BOE 2026-06-18.
- galiciapress.es: Galiciapress 2026-09-29.
- trans.info: trans.info 2026-08-24, transport firm count and 30.
- bolsamania.com: Europa Press 2026-01-09, UNO 20, 000-driver deficit.
- cadenadesuministro.es: Cadena de Suministro 2026-10-15.
- cadenadesuministro.es: Cadena de Suministro 2026-10-15.
- cadenadesuministro.es: site identity.
- forocoches.com: Forocoches thread 2014 to 2015.
- idom.com: IDOM APS page, Excel admission (vendor).
- demandsolutionslatam.com: Demand Solutions Latam.
- sadio.org.ar: Vidoni and Vecchietti, SII 2015 (JAIIO).
- amelica.org: Revista Mutis 2022.
- deloitte.com: Deloitte Chile and CESCO study page 2026 (full report behind a form).
- redimin.cl: REDIMIN 2026-06-24 on the Deloitte/CESCO study.
- forbes.cl: Forbes Chile 2026-04-15, Accenture quote on scaling.
- cesco.cl: CESCO podcast summary 2026-08-07.
- biobiochile.cl: BioBioChile 2025-07-10.
- sonami.cl: 4DIGITAL deck hosted by SONAMI.
- mundomaritimo.cl: MundoMaritimo 2022-06-13.
- laccei.org: LACCEI 2026 paper.
- icex.es: ICEX smart agro Peru 2025 summary.
- agrolatam.com: Agrolatam 2025-06-15.
- blogdelcontador.com.ar: Argentina KIT 4.0 programme note 2026-04-27.
- smio.org: SMIO site.
- ichio.cl: ICHIO site.
- alio.org: redirected to a GoDaddy parking page on 2026-10-16.
- tramitapp.com: TramitApp (vendor), nurse rostering.
- decidesoluciones.es: Decide Soluciones (vendor) write-up of LogisTalks panel with Logistop.
Poland, Czechia and Slovakia, Russian-speaking space
- benchmark.pl: BPSC survey of 350 Polish manufacturers 2016-04-07.
- money.pl: Siemens / Ministry "Smart Industry Polska 2017".
- itwiz.pl: ITwiz 2025-08-18 on DPS Group report, ERP 30 %.
- opolskie.pl: Opolskie regional survey, n = 150, 2025-11.
- kongresobywatelski.pl: Śledziewska and Włoch, Polish SMEs and Industry 4.0.
- nexelem.com: Polish production-management event calendar.
- ciirc.cvut.cz: CIIRC summary of NCP 4.0 Analýza 1/2023.
- ncp40.cz: NCP 4.0 Analýza českého průmyslu 1/2023, full PDF.
- ncp40.cz: NCP 4.0 editions list.
- spcr.cz: Svaz průmyslu a dopravy, Industry 4.0 page.
- adastracorp.com: Adastra workshop survey 2024-12-02 (vendor.
- systemonline.cz: Fárek (ITeuro, Infor partner), IT Systems 6/2025.
- technickytydenik.cz: Figura (K2), Technický týdeník 2021-11-07.
- systemonline.cz: Komenda (inSophy), IT Systems 9/2014.
- systemonline.cz: Komenda (inSophy), IT Systems 7-8/2013.
- systemonline.cz: Plaček (Merz), IT Systems 7-8/2008, user view.
- issek.hse.ru: HSE ISSEK.
- expert.ru: Expert.ru 2025-07-13, Reksoft estimates.
- isicad.ru: Samoylov (ASCON-Samara, Preactor integrator).
- up-pro.ru: BIA Technologies 2023-12-20.
- habr.com: Rightstep (consultancy).
- habr.com: comment thread under the above.
- habr.com: Rightstep, "Недовнедренная ERP в производстве".
- habr.com: "rebuilder".
- habr.com: comment thread, driver pay and trackers.
- vc.ru: Prozorov.
- rustore.ru: Yandex Routing driver app, rating 2.0 from 55.
- habr.com: Karpov, MES at a steel radiator plant, 2019-11-20.
- habr.com: CS Group / Dassault, DELMIA Ortems load test.
- habr.com: Lozhkins, driver rostering for LTL routes.
- education.ua: Nikushin (FADO, Ukraine), route optimisation payback.
- habr.com: Dodo Engineering, VRP with OR-Tools, 2025-04-29.
- habr.com: X5 Tech, retail optimisation on synthetic data.
- t.me: Telegram "{ PRO Планирование | IBP }".
- selunion.ru: National Union of Transport and Logistics Experts.
- retail.ru: Ozon staffing algorithms, company release 2026-05-07.
- vc.ru: "Natalia", digitalisation consultant.
Gulf, Egypt, Morocco
- ieomsociety.org: Alkhalefah (KSU), IEOM GCC 2026.
- ieomsociety.org: IEOM GCC proceedings index.
- thenationalnews.com: The National 2025-11-13 on McKinsey GCC AI survey.
- thenationalnews.com: The National 2026-05-04, Al Nowais interview.
- swp-berlin.org: SWP Comment 2023, Ansari and Werenfels.
- theartnewspaper.com: The Art Newspaper 2025-12-09.
- gerad.ca: Er Raqabi et al., OCP supply chain for Africa.
- ideas.repec.org: abstract of Becker, Bertsimas et al..
- financialafrik.com: Financial Afrik 2021-01-18, OCP Edelman finalist.
- iaorifors.com: IFORS abstract of Helbing et al..
- weforum.org: WEF 2023, Saudi SME modernisation, NPP and KAMIN.
- saudipedia.com: Future Factories Program.
- aawsat.com: Asharq Al-Awsat 2024-07-25, 479 SIRI assessments.
- moiat.gov.ae: MoIAT 2024-06-13, ITTI 400+ companies.
- middleeastainews.com: Middle East AI News 2026-06-14 on GASTAT ICT survey 2025 (AI-assisted newsletter).
- vision2030.ai: third-party NIDLP tracker, "indicative" figures.
- rigzone.com: Rigzone Saudi job listings (Aramco LP posting itself not opened).
- joc.com: JOC 2011-04-04.
- raqi.com: Raqi Technologies, Arabic guide for Saudi merchants.
- clarionshipping.com: Clarion Shipping (Dubai 3PL) blog.
- softwaredisruption.com: Software Disruption FZCO, Dubai (vendor).
- alwatan.com.sa: Al-Watan column "بحوث العمليات", 2022-07-24.
China
- cygnusequity.com: 高鹄资本 intelligent APS note, 2022-09 (investment bank.
- paper.people.com.cn: 中国城市报 2026-04-06, 86.92 % figure.
- rmlt.com.cn: 学习时报 essay 2024-03-18, RMB 1.5 m average project.
- e-works.net.cn: e-works search page with summaries of its 2026 APS series and roundtable (articles not opened).
- blog.csdn.net: OR engineer's three employers, 2022-08-14.
- developer.jdcloud.com: JD Retail supply-chain planning algorithms 2025-05-12 (in-house.
- sohu.com: 张鑫航 (Cainiao), OR in practice, DataFun 2023-11-18.
- scm-blog.com: 刘宝红 on the status of planning, 2026-03-30.
- cloud.tencent.com: "APS为什么成功率低?" 2020-07-22.
- zhihu.com: 王源 talk write-up, 运筹OR帷幄, edited 2026-01-29.
- news.qq.com: 蒙绎泽 (清智优化) ArchSummit transcript 2024-08-29 (vendor.
- bbs.csdn.net: CSDN bbs.
- bbs.csdn.net: CSDN bbs.
- zhihu.com: Zhihu question on APS becoming "高级Excel"; 悠桦林 and 亿澳斯 answers (vendor).
- zhihu.com: Zhihu question on APS failure rate; 悠桦林 answer with client list and unsourced figures (vendor).
- zhihu.com: Zhihu question on why APS is hard to land; Lu Jie answer.
- zhihu.com: 老贱 column 2026-03-26 (promotes 简道云, partly vendor).
- qt-asia.com: 科箭 TMS, route optimisation landing.
- smartcomma.com: 逗号科技 routing case with footnote (vendor.
- goodo-tech.com: 谷斗科技 on landing difficulties 2025-08-29 (vendor.
- zhihu.com: 张成义 OR engineer career column (2019, edited 2022).
- ifenxi.com: 爱分析 interview with 杉数 王曦 (undated.
- andafa.com: 安达发 APS FAQ, duration and price (vendor).
- sohu.com: 章月洲 "一个失败的APS案例" 2021-11-11 (APS salesman on a competitor's failure).
- 36kr.com: 邬爱其, 复旦《管理视野》 "200家工厂" 2025-11-19 (academic essay).
- ndrc.gov.cn: NDRC reprint 2021-07-28.
- sugli.sjtu.edu.cn: SJTU, ORSC 运筹应用奖 2020.
- orsc.org.cn: ORSC ASA2026 conference report 2026-04-24.
- conf.orsc.org.cn: ORSC 企业运筹学分会 19th annual meeting notice.
- zhihu.com: 运筹OR帷幄 column.
- scmor.com: 2023 Wuhan 智能优化应用实践研讨会 programme.
- zhihu.com: DataFunSummit 2023 OR forum agenda.
- zhihu.com: 王磊 (Alibaba Cloud), DataFunTalk 2023-09-26.
English baseline
- or.stackexchange.com: OR Stack Exchange 2019.
- reddit.com: r/OperationsResearch 2024-09-16.
- reddit.com: r/OperationsResearch 2025-07-19.
- reddit.com: r/OperationsResearch 2026-01, sports scheduling.
- reddit.com: r/supplychain 2026-09-15.
- reddit.com: r/supplychain 2025-08-29.
- reddit.com: r/supplychain 2025-07-12, suites "overkill".
- reddit.com: r/logistics 2026-06-06.
- news.ycombinator.com: Ask HN 2025-01-29.
- nextmv.io: Nextmv (vendor blog) interview with Doug Gray (Walmart) and Karla Hoffman.
- timefold.ai: Timefold (vendor), De Smet, failure modes.
- decisionbrain.com: DecisionBrain (vendor) statistics compilation citing Deloitte 2024 and 2025 (originals not opened).
- chalmers.se: Kjellsdotter Ivert and Jonsson 2011, IJPDLM.
- shura.shu.ac.uk: Drake 2017, Health Informatics Journal.
- supplychainbrain.com: SupplyChainBrain 2003-11-01.
- genpact.com: Genpact (consultancy) 2021, planner overrides.
- mckinsey.com: McKinsey (consultancy), APS survey n = 80, Nov 2025.
- linkedin.com: Dave Medd post, McKinsey 10 % figure second-hand.
- linkedin.com: Lora Cecere article 2025-12-24, satisfaction numbers.
- supplychainshaman.com: Lora Cecere blog 2025-12-05.
- abcsupplychain.com: AbcSupplyChain survey 2025-11-25.
- gams.com: EURO Practitioners' Forum 2026 programme.
- youtube.com: Microsoft 2026 Edelman presentation; transcript read from a search snippet only (Tavily).